Query 1: Question On Gita and Love. Two important facets of Spirituality is Love and Compassion. We should
have selfless love towards every being. How could one love God, when one cannot love his brother? Another
dimension to this is to have compassion towards the suffering and to serve them. We should try alleviate the
sufferings of the suffering. My question is: How does the Bhagavad Gita inspire us to do the above? I am
asking this as the famed scriptures does not seem to actively promote Love all, Serve
Query 2: >Compassion is a word with a broad
meaning. Today if I find on the road a person being beaten mercilessly ... would I try to help one. No! One reaps
the fruits of his Karma ... Vivekananda tried to help the community ... he got lost on the path of spirituality and
did not gain Self Realization which he badly wanted to.
If this is the case, then no one needs to help another? Every one on the
Spiritual path should not help others or do charity at all? What is the motivation in Religion to lend a
helping hand along the way? After all, Buddha, the Enlightened One, is known to have taken care of a leper
monk when other monks stood away and was willing to slice his flesh to feed hungry eaglets. Christ, Shirdi
Sai Baba etc. have all been known to show an example.
Yes, I however agree that a person who dedicates their life to service
like Mother Teresa may enter heavan but not Liberation and it is much more effective to serve after
enlightenment. In one of Yogananda's writings, Swami Vivekananda is shown to have used yogic powers to save
one of Yogananda's disciples, Janakananda, when the latter was a small boy. However, I suppose Vivekananda is
Query 3: I think I have never mentioned this to you before, but I am an undergraduate. I find that
it is difficult to practise Karma Yoga as a student and be fully detached from the fruits of actions (exam results)
and be even-minded in pain and pleasure. What do you suggest? While answering, please remember the maxim, "it is
easier said than done"
We should have??? We should be doing so many good things in life ... Do
we really practice what we preach! Why does a Spiritual person have compassion and love for everybody ... as
and when one elevates himself Spiritually ... we go farther and farther away from the physical manifest form
... we tend to see the divinity within every form ... we start loving every creature, every form, every Jiva
because one is an embodiment of atman the soul within ... which is of the same essence as God, the Omnipotent
For an ordinary human being, who lives a physical manifested life ... it
is very difficult to practice brotherhood with all. If it were so, it would not have been the present bad
times that we face today (the present Kali Yuga) ... it would have been Satyuga (the Golden period). Life in
his cycle ... we have both bad and good times. So is the law of Karma ... we cannot deviate from it, come
Most people Pray to God not for the sake of it but they fear God and hence they seek his blessings. One who pays to
God in its truest sense ... he never despises anyone ... friend or foe, for he sees in one the image of God as you
Compassion is a word with a broad meaning. Today if I find on the road a
person being beaten mercilessly ... would I try to help one. No! One reaps the fruits of his Karma ...
Vivekananda tried to help the community ... he got lost on the path of spirituality and did not gain Self
Realization which he badly wanted to.
An ordinary human being must try to help one another but for how long ... whether we must help one or not is
prompted by our Atman within ... why at all should we think about it. Once I tried to help a person (a sikh
gentleman) lying in pool of blood ... I and my companions saw the truck which hit his motorcycle ... yet his
parents tried to put the blame on us. It does not mean we must not help people in need but we have to work as per
the merits of the case.
Bhagavad Gita is a very way broad document ... it encompasses everything.
You are slightly away from the path. Bhagavad Gita deals only with the innerself ... it does not give much
importance to the outer covering ... the body of a human being. It promotes doing the right Karma so that
atman the soul within gets liberated at the earliest from the cycle of birth and death. The physical aspect
of Spirituality is discussed more in Ramayana that teaches one to rise to the level of Rama... one who for the sake of his
father abandoned the throne and went to the Jungles for a long period of 14 years.
As per Bhagavad Gita, all atmans souls are independent ... only after they manifest a body the relationship
develops. All being sons and daughters of God ... we become brothers and sisters. It is not vice versa. Bhagavad
Gita never advocates one to become like Mother Teresa ... many can perform social service ... but how many travel
the pure path of spirituality and Realize God within their lifetime ... not one in a billion! Bhagavad Gita
inherently provokes one to continue walking the right path in spite of all the hurdles one might face in life.
While proceeding on the path of pure Spirituality ... we may sometimes neglect the physical aspect of life ...
failing to serve individuals so that one may serve the total mankind ultimately.
This is the path I have followed.
>If this is the case, then no one needs to help another? Every one
on the Spiritual path should not help others or do charity at all?
I simply quoted my case ... normal Human Beings including those on the
path of spirituality follow a different path ... we inherently tend to help out one in need ... this purely
depends on our Karma ... one cannot expect the same attitude from a hard-core criminal walking the path way.
If you try to help someone it is because you have an inherent tendency ... those who don't do not care at
The meaning of word charity is varied ... I need a million dollar to
establish a Satyuga ... are there any who are willing to listen! With passage of time I know my inherent wish
would be fulfilled but not right now. There are numerous instances of money being loitered without much
thought, yet we have to sustain all. Absolute pure charity means helping the mankind as a whole and should
not be limited to a particular sect, Religion, institution or a country. Every act is charitable which earns
us Punya, otherwise not. Giving charity for the sake of it ... for earning a name in the society is no
charity at all.
>What is the motivation in Religion to lend a helping hand along the way? After all, Buddha, the Enlightened
One, is known to have taken care of a leper monk when other monks stood away and was willing to slice his flesh to
feed hungry eaglets. Christ, Shirdi Sai Baba etc. have all been known to show an example.
Buddha wanted to help one because he found the leper monk to be a
truthful person (which I hope he would have been) ... once we come to know that the present life is our last
manifestation on Mother Earth ... we tend to make the best use of it ... be it relieving one from his
I remember the moment I had Realized God ... I had a very strong urge for three days ... only if I could have
touched a dying body ... one could have got up hail and hearty. Something within prompted me from carrying out such
so-called miracles. A mere glaze from me could have made sick people all right. But that was not to be. I have been
against miracles since childhood. Probably, it was best for that period.
Religion primarily motivates people in following an almost fixed path ...
the one followed by their leader. Religion tends to combine people and keep them under an umbrella ... it is
not Religion which motivates people but the inherent Spirituality in all beings which guides us on the right
path ... when we follow our Spiritual leader ... we do not follow him but we tend to follow the hidden
meaning behind his Spiritual teachings ... those hard-core truths which keep one away from vices. Physical
aspect of helping one is only a fraction of what one can accomplish Spiritually.
>In one of Yogananda's writings, Swami Vivekananda is shown to have used yogic powers to save one of
Yogananda's disciples, Janakananda, when the latter was a small boy. However, I suppose Vivekananda is not
Vivekananda practiced pure Spirituality ... he was not religiously
inclined. He definitely had the support of God. Miracles, definitely can be performed by only those Spiritual
people who are true at heart and practice absolutely pure Spirituality. Those who tend to show that they have
miraculous powers ... are mere Tantriks who believe in the show of their power ... such people cannot
It is never difficult to practice Karma Yoga at any stage of life ...
only your understanding of the term Karma Yoga is at variation ... Karma Yoga does not only mean as as you
have referred ... has a very broad meaning.
Why you are a student? There must be some goal behind it ... something
you want to achieve in life. If after having achieved that goal ... you indulge your self in materialistic
pursuits ... you definitely are after the fruits of Karma. King Janaka ... father of Sita (wife of Rama) is
the only example in the history of India who was a perfect Karma Yogi in his times. He did whatever was
expected of a King ... rather fulfilled his duty as a King ... his aim was never to enjoy life as a King ...
rather he wanted to serve the society which he could better serve only if he became the King ... and he
You as a student must never hamper after the marks or getting
better education ... but once you have a goal ... you definitely would strive to come first in class ... for you
have a duty to fulfill. Rather you must strive for perfection in everything you do. Exams are only a means to keep
the student in check ... they serve no other purpose.
Every moment of your life must be spent in achieving your aim of life ...
I would advise you here that you must possess which have been recommended by me in my various newsletters.
They shall help you concentrate on a certain goal and then help achieve it. I consider these books more
valuable than the Bible.
I know it is difficult not to experience pain and pleasure ... more difficult is to maintain the equilibrium
between the two. Reading about- Nimitta (Predestined course of
life) and Niyati (Predestined) in my Glossary would
clarify your doubts to a certain extent.
Always there to clarify your queries (send your query),
Vijay Kumar "Atma Jnani" ... The Man who Realized God in 1993!
A to Z of Question On Gita and Love explained in words one can easily understand and fathom.
For more on question on gita and love visit : http://www.vijaykumar.com/Bhagavad-Gita/
... Vijay Kumar - 5th June 2010.
Top of page